The other day we were eating and Mother
asked Alesia how she liked the DVD we watched called True Women. Alesia thought
a moment, then said she liked how the men in the story were so caring and
sensitive to their wives, and didn’t hit them. I must have looked
startled or even horrified because Alesia reads my face and when I tried to get
her to clarify what she meant, she got nervous and wouldn’t say more. Sometimes
she lets slip little remarks like that and I am reminded that her views are so
naïve, and also so off kilter because of her early life.
I think Alesia’s feeling is that a lot of
men hit their wives, and that violence is common in male-female relationships.
I imagine that in her first 6 years with her birthmom, she probably saw the
birthmom hit, possibly even beaten. There were a lot of different men in and
out of her birthmom’s life, and they were not all nice men. There was a lot of
alcohol abuse. So her first view as a small child was that warped one. One has
to deduce, then, that she thinks that’s the way it is everywhere.
Mother told me from the time I was an
adolescent, “You never, ever, let a man get away with hitting you – you
leave. If they hit you one time, they will do it again, so just get away from
them.” Mother repeated this to Alesia. She was almost shaking, she was so
vehement in what she said. I kept quiet. Alesia listened intently. I remember
the first time I heard it, and how powerful it was to me. Mother went on to say to both kids, it’s never OK for
anyone to hit you. Never.
I read recently that children who are
physically abused always blame themselves for the violence. They always think
it was their fault, that they caused it. I remember that being expressed so
powerfully at the end of the movie Good Will Hunting. Both my kids were abused.
Michael has talked about his mother hitting him, and some of her boyfriends hit
him. His medical record has notes about hematomas on his face due to being hit,
when he was less than 5 years old. Alesia’s birthmom spanked her and the bigger
girls at the orphanage beat her. The important question that always bothers me
is, how do I convince them that the violence they encountered was not their
fault? It’s easy to say that, but far more difficult to convince someone that
they never deserved to be hit.
I started doing some research, and came
across this article, which I found really interesting. The passage I
found most disturbing was this, about abuse from a parent or caregiver and how it feels to the child:
If my caregiver loves
me, and I love my caregiver, but my caregiver is hitting, punching, or throwing
me, it must mean that there is something that I am doing wrong, or, there is
something terribly wrong with me at a very basic level. I am bad. In addition, a kind of guilt feeling arises surrounding the
child’s inability to protect themselves from the abuse. Out of these emotions,
an intense feeling of being different from other children and the need to hide
the facts surrounding the negative emotions begins to flow.
I think my kids feel deeply that they are
different, possibly even “bad,” at least part of the time. No matter how many
times I tell them differently (or Granny, or the therapist) they do not think
they are the same as, or as good as, other kids. Alesia is more transparent in
her negative feelings, but Michael has them, too. The biggest evidence I see of
it is their deep insecurity. They do not want to share Mom, with each other or
anyone else. They crave the routine and familiar. They fear change. They have a very hard time making friends. Obviously,
most kids feel that way to some extent, but my kids feel it more intensely
because of the nightmares they’ve already endured.
We were headed to the beach a couple of
years ago, shortly after we got Michael, and there was a flat tire on the car.
Both kids told me later it was the most scary thing that they had ever been
through. Now, my brother lived nearby, and he came and changed the tire for us
and everything was fine. They had no frame of reference for that, however.
I don’t know exactly what to do to help my
kids process and overcome the terrible things they’ve endured. I pray a lot. I
read everything I can find. I try to tell them every day how much I love them.
I take them to therapy. I warn them to never let anyone hit them. That’s all I know to do.
One day I hope I can say to them about their
abusive pasts, “It was not your fault,” and they will believe me.
Recent Comments