Doctors are not always right. They are human. They don't always understand the mysteries of the human body, or the fact that not all of us fit the norm. I just wish doctors would take a more holistic approach when they are prescribing.
I posted something on Facebook yesterday that I just thought was useful information, not trying to cause controversy, and it sparked a bunch of comments. Leg cramps are painful and scary and my mom has suffered with them for years.
So despite the fact that I am not a nurse or a doctor, I KNOW about leg cramps. I've gotten them too. Horrible feeling. I've had foot cramps, too. No fun.
My post: My mom gets bad leg cramps and over the years we've learned what helps. If you get leg cramps you need a product called No Salt - it has tons of potassium, and that's what your body needs to fight the leg cramps. Also, Lay's potato chips have lots of potassium. Another helper is tonic water, which has quinine. When my mom gets bad leg cramps I grab the potato chips and tonic water and it really helps her. You can find tonic water at any grocery store. (Adding some fresh lime juice helps the taste.)
A friend of mine who has a medical degree and was a doctor before she had kids, posted this: "I read a review article in one of my medical journals abt leg cramps and low potassium was pretty far down the list of causes - number one cause is dehydration, followed by muscle fatigue, low magnesium, low calcium and peripheral artery disease in elderly. Ppl always want to blame potassium. A review article summarizes all the research data over the last few years."
She is a sweet lady and well-intentioned. She has a point about the studies. I am very much in favor of scientific studies.
However, my mother is not typical. My mother is a Hasty. One of my distant cousins on the Hasty side posted this response: "I, like Dee, am a Hasty. A couple of years ago, at a first cousins get together, I asked about potassium deficiency. Half of us were on prescription potassium supplements. I was in emergency room when they found mine. One other cousin ended up in hospital before they found his - not sure about the rest. Sodium shortage tends to show up only with dehydration - but my tests often show low side of normal so I never try to cut back on it."
So our family tends to suffer a lot of leg cramps, and deficiencies in potassium and sodium, and potassium helps the cramps.
My mom tends to have diarrhea a lot, and her potassium and sodium get flushed out of her body. About 15 years ago she had a bad bout and couldn't keep food down, and I finally took her to the emergency room. They ran tests and told me all her mineral levels - potassium, sodium, etc. - were so low, she was hours away from dying.
They gave her potassium.
Yes, she was dehydrated. Yes, the studies show that was the cause of her issues. But why is she dehydrated? Could it be that her body just doesn't hold onto the potassium?
Not to be gross, but the big prescription potassium pills just exit her body without breaking down at.all.
My point is simply this: human beings are not all alike, and some of us are wired differently. Doctors tend to figure out what works best for most people and apply that to everyone. However, it doesn't always work for particular individuals.
Point #2:
My dad was in the hospital some years ago for an aortic aneurysm. He was given Librium, a tranquilizer. It had the opposite effect on him. It made him hyper and CRAZY. Not tranquil. Not even close. He had to be tied to the bed. I was there with him for hours, watching this, and it was horrifying. The nurses kept giving him the Librium and wouldn't listen to me. The doctor wouldn't change the orders until I got her on the phone and threatened to sue her.
Dad had weird body chemistry. I shouldn't have had to threaten the doctor to get the orders changed. The nurses were there to see how loony he was. I think they were scared of the doctor, though. I wasn't.
Point #3:
I've had people tell me frankly that I was nuts for tapping painful spots with a magnet. Well it's not traditional, no. It's not even well known. However, it WORKS. It costs almost nothing. It's non-invasive. Nobody knows why it works. The effects are not permanent. However, I tap my mother's arthritic knee every night, and her sore neck, and she gets temporary relief.
Lay's potato chips and tonic water give her relief from leg cramps.
Counterpoint
Doctors sometimes prescribe "off label." This is a bit scary but so what? If evidence shows a drug being effective for something not on the label, why not prescribe it, and monitor the patient carefully?
I am taking a drug called Neurontin, for menopause-like symptoms that made me miserable a few months ago. It works. I am perfectly fine, as long as I take it. If I stop, I feel awful. Now, here is the stated use, on label, for it:
Neurontin (gabapentin) is an anti-epileptic medication, also called an anticonvulsant. It affects chemicals and nerves in the body that are involved in the cause of seizures and some types of pain.
My gynecologist prescribed it and I was VERY hesitant to take it for my symptoms. I wasn't having seizures. I wasn't in any pain. However, I was desperate. I felt woozy and nauseated all the time, and I was miserable.
Conclusion
So my point is that I am not trying to say doctors are stupid or don't listen to them. Most of the time they are right. However, if you have an unusual family history, like the Hastys, or if you're like Dad and become hyper when given a tranquilizer, you need to find a doctor who respects that information.
Inform your doctor of weird things in your family history. Talk to cousins and aunts and uncles and LEARN your family medical history, as much as possible.
Educate yourself about things like magnets that work on pain. Don't fall for quackery, of course, but keep an open mind.
I learn fascinating stuff all the time. My arthritis symptoms are non-existent as long as I take Omega 3 fish oil pills every day.
I am learning more and more every day about the benefits of coconut oil.
So non-doctors: educate yourself.
Doctors: y'all need to LISTEN to your patients. You need to spend more than 5 minutes with them when you see them. You need to understand not just their symptoms, but what they eat, their bathroom habits, their stresses. Human beings are complicated.
Here endeth the lesson...
Mom and her brother Bobby and his wife Myrtle, late 1970's
Recent Comments