I like to watch a show called Finding Your Roots, hosted by Henry Louis Gates, on PBS. I am always fascinated by the ancestors of any celebrity, even celebs I have never heard of before -- by the end of the show it feels like they are a friend, no matter what their age or occupation or background.
Here's something we ALL have in common: we all have ancestors that did things that we find... disturbing? Appalling? Just weird?
I have often wondered what I would say if Dr. Gates ever dug into my family tree and presented me with a Book of Life, or one of those cool charts showing your forebears.
I have always thought most of my ancestors were simple farmers, folks who likely owned no slaves.
I'm wrong.
I have learned over the past year or so that a number of my ancestors owned slaves. I cannot change that. What I've often pondered is, should I apologize for it? Should I be ashamed of those folks?
I don't know. I don't think so.
above, my great great grandparents John T. Hasty and his wife Sarah, (Sarah was half Cherokee)
On the one hand, since my children and I are mixed race, not lily-white, any of us, I feel I shouldn't have to apologize or even feel bad. I have ancestors who likely WERE slaves, not just slave owners.
On the other hand, wouldn't a sensitive, kind, caring person feel the need to apologize for having slaveholder DNA?
What troubles me is that there are folks in this country who will be very critical of me for simply saying that I don't feel great remorse for what my ancestors did. In the politically-correct view, I should be ashamed to be southern, ashamed to come from such a racist place, ashamed of my people, going as far back as anyone cares to trace.
As a logical argument, though, let's just say I decided to swallow all the shame and regret and righteous indignation that one might assign to me in the politically-correct universe likely inhabited by most PBS viewers. Where would the apologies stop? How far back would I have to go, and how much research would it take?
What if I apologized for my evil ancestors and then realized, as I did recently, that I am related to Thomas Jefferson? He was a slave owner, yes, but he was also brilliant and a key figure in forming the United States. Do his good deeds outweigh the bad? Historians likely all have an opinion on that.
I'm also related to George Washington. Slaveholder, yes, but without him we would likely still be English subjects.
One of my cousins traced our ancestry all the way back to England, to John of Gaunt. He was the ancestor to a lot of English kings who liked to chop people's heads off. Should I track down the descendants of all those headless folks and apologize?
If I feel shame and regret and remorse for my ancestors -- and I am not saying I do -- then logically I should take on their sins and try to ameliorate them. How much atonement is enough? How many good deeds have to be attributed to me before I am absolved? How do I undo what was done decades or even centuries before I was born? Where would it end? Who would decide it had ended?
Let's simplify things a bit.
The clearest indicator to me that I am not like my ancestors is just next door. My next door neighbors on one side are a mixed race couple, a white man and a black woman. They are more than neighbors. They are friends. They are the type of friends I can call and say "I am so sick and Lola desperately needs a walk" and they will walk her for me -- until I am completely well. They did that not long ago, in fact. They have brought me groceries when I couldn't leave Mom and Michael wasn't available. They are two of the finest people I know.
My neighbors on the other side are Asian. My neighbors a few doors down are a gay couple. Many of my neighbors are Roman Catholic. We are all friendly. I love my neighbors.
I have slaveholder DNA and yet I don't hate any other races. I have Huguenot DNA and yet I don't hate Roman Catholics. I have South Georgia redneck DNA but I have friends from all over the United States.
Some of my ancestors would likely be appalled by my declarations in the paragraphs above. They would also be appalled, I am sure, that I got DNA testing done and learned I am .5% black and not only am I not ashamed, I am delighted. I am delighted to know some of my Hasty ancestors were Cherokee. I've always suspected I was not purely European, and in my view that's a good thing. (Purebred animals are usually high-strung and not hearty -- give me a mutt dog any day, not some purebred ninny that's super high maintenance.)
above, my ancestor CC Phillips
My great grandmother Beulah Phillips Butler was the daughter of a Confederate veteran (see above). There are confederate soldiers on the Hasty side, too, and so on and so forth. I wish they had not owned slaves. I wish they were more forward-thinking than that. I wish I could travel back in time and undo whatever awful things they might have done.
I cannot, however.
I'd like to travel back in time and take back things I've said and done. I can't. None of us can.
The bible says "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone." In my view that means "don't judge." I don't have the right to judge anyone's choices. If I had lived back then, in the 19th century, undoubtedly I would have had a very different worldview than I do now. We are all products of the times in which we are born.
Perhaps one day my grandchildren and great-grandchildren will look back and say "Wow, Memaw Dee sure had some wacky ideas! Glad she's not around now to embarrass us!"
There are two ways to live one's life -- going around passing judgment on everyone and everything, which is pretty normal behavior for most of us -- and choosing to consciously NOT do that. I have lived both ways, and I can tell you that making a conscious choice to not be judgmental of other people is by far the more healthy thing to do.
Filling your soul with judgmental thoughts is like filling yourself with something foul and rank. It accomplishes nothing good.
Instead of condemning my ancestors, I prefer to celebrate them. I like to learn as much as I can about them. I like to see places they lived and see photos or paintings of them, to see if I look like them.
My ancestors, some of them, survived religious persecution in France and came to America to start over. That took courage. The French Huguenots were tortured, and some were burned at the stake, for their faith.
Some of my ancestors survived the Scottish clearances, and came to America to start over.
My Cherokee ancestors survived having their land and homes ripped away, and many were marched to death on the Trail of Tears.
My ancestors survived the awful Reconstruction time, when the south was beaten down and people starved, when the Klan rose to fame and Jim Crow became the terrible law of the land.
My ancestors survived the Great Depression. All four of my grandparents suffered a lot of hardships during that time, but they survived. Their children all grew up, went to college, started families, prospered.
My parents survived being young and poor and they worked hard and they made a good life for us.
We are all products of all the choices made by all the people who went before us. Good choices, bad choices -- we are all products of a million choices made over many, many generations. It's not my place for me to judge my ancestors harshly, or judge their choices. It's not the place of my descendants to judge me.
I am going into the Christmas season this year happy to have survived another year, although there were a lot of hardships this past year. We survived. We held onto our faith. We were given much help and love from family, friends, and neighbors.
I do not know what next year holds.
I do know this: I am alive and I am strong because the people whose DNA is in my body were strong. They were resilient. They endured, and even prospered, surviving hardships and heartaches I can only imagine.
God bless them.
I am grateful for their courage and tenacity.
I am grateful technology allows me to learn more about them, and about the times in which they lived.
I am grateful I do not bear any malice in my heart for anyone whose color, race, religion, or background are different from mine.
Because of those ancestors, I am alive, and I have a chance to do good deeds, and pass along a little wisdom, faith, and courage to the next generations.
Because of those who have gone before, I can pass along my love to lots of people, related and unrelated, and they can pass along love -- like ripples, spreading out endlessly.
I think that's the most important thing that God really asks of us, to love expansively and extravagantly.
photo by Linda Hasty Harris
Recent Comments