I had never heard the term "helicopter parent" until about 10-15 years ago when I read an article about that type of parenting and realized a woman I worked with was the epitome of a Helicopter Mom. I listened to her talk about parenting like it was the most exhaustive thing in the world, and I remember feeling sorry for her.
Now, I was raised by a stay at home mom and my colleague had a full-time job but those weren't the only differences.
Every moment of the day was scheduled for Helicopter Mom. Her children took lessons, got tutored, and had play dates. Her children were professionally photographed at least twice a year. Their birthday parties cost $300 or more -- just for the special party stuff. Much more was spent on a cake, presents, and swag bags for the other kids.
They were expected to make all A's and she did their homework with them every night.
I knew her before I adopted my kids and I remember thinking wow, I so don't want to parent like she does.
Now, to be fair, both her kids are honors students. Nice kids. Probably will go far in life. [I know this because they went to the same school as my kids and I would see Helicopter Mom occasionally and chat, although our friendship didn't survive me leaving that company.]
What made me think of her was that yesterday I was reading a review of a book called Achtung Baby: An American Mom on the German Art of Raising Self-Reliant Children, by Sara Zaske and I was fascinated and horrified to read of how differently children are raised in Germany and America. The German method sounds pretty awesome. American helicopter parenting?!? Sounds ridiculous, in comparison. Zaske moved to Germany with her husband when she had a toddler and was pregnant, and lived there several years.
More about the book, from Amazon:
As opposed to the stereotype of strict, overbearing German parent, Zaske found "free-range" was the norm for childhood. In Germany today, children are encouraged to walk to school on their own and talk honestly about the Holocaust and other painful moments in the past. The priority is raising children who are self-reliant, independent, and responsible: a stark contrast, says Zaske, to the results some experts see from American children in the "helicopter" parenting era. From the birth process (in which midwives are the most common attendants) to early childhood (child care is considered a right, and "kita" schools provide playtime instead of the more rigorous American-style education) to elementary school (where topics such as sex, death, and nudity are a part of everyday conversations and outdoor time is enforced daily), Zaske compares American and German parenting culture and gives the U.S. reader inspiration to explore new methods.
I realized as I was researching this interesting book that I was raised much more in the German style than in the current American helicopter style, and I am very glad about that. I was a "free range" kid who didn't know differently.
My favorite activity from ages 5 or 6 until age 7 or 8 was to make mud pies in the back yard. I considered myself the mud pie queen.
I also liked to go exploring in the woods behind our house in Augusta -- usually by myself. My brother and I fished in the creek that ran through the woods, and swam in it [Ray's Creek, in Augusta]. We didn't concern ourselves with snakes or sunscreen. One day we walked for miles in the creek, pretending we were on safari in Africa, neither of us wearing shirts.
left, me at age 3 at my brother's 6th birthday party - I never wore shoes
Mom wasn't watching us every minute. The rule was, we had to tell her where we were going if we left our yard, and she enforced that. However, we went all over the neighborhood and played, only coming home at dark, many times. We played football in the street. We rode bicycles everywhere.
When we moved to Knoxville, when I was 8, I remember spending entire afternoons outside sledding when it snowed. We got a lot of snow the winter of 1971.
below left, me sledding in Knoxville, age 8 // below right, me on my bike, age 6, Augusta
We were daredevils. In hot weather we roller skated down the steep hill leading to our house, or rode our bikes down the hill.
I remember spending countless days at the beach or at the swimming pool without parental supervision. (My older brother was often told to watch me but he usually didn't.)
When we bought the cabin on Douglas Lake I usually fixed my own breakfast and lunch [ages 8-16] and what I did during the day was my business. My brother and I swam, made rafts, swung from a rope swing and dropped into the lake, played tennis on an old court nearby, read books, picked blackberries, etc. We were outdoor kids, water babies.
Since my brother and I were both fair-haired and blue-eyed we had really fair skin, and I recall Mom slathering us with Sea & Ski before going to the pool but she was actually considered a bit overprotective for doing it. We got burned many times for not getting it reapplied.
My mother was never an activities director worried about what I did every second of the day. Not at all. In fact, I learned early that if I ever said "I'm bored" I would be told "Well I have plenty of chores around the house that you can do." She wasn't kidding. I learned how to do my own laundry when I was 8. I could cook a full meal at age 10.
Grades were not a big deal, for me. If I made a C they would ask me why but I don't recall making any C's until high school. Mom or Dad would ask me if I did my homework, most weeknights, but I had usually done it on the bus or while lying on the floor of the den watching the 4 p.m. movie. I don't recall homework ever taking more than 30 minutes until I was in high school. I don't recall my parents ever fussing at me about any report card until I got into high school and nearly failed Algebra my freshman year.
I have few recollections of "play dates" as a child because my playmates almost always lived within walking distance -- a mile or two. Sometimes parents would organize trips to the roller skating rink or the movies, with a group.
I started going to the movies without my parents when I was about 7. There was always an older child with me, you understand, and we were taken and picked up at the door to the theater, but parents today would never do that, I'm sure.
So much of my childhood was spent outside playing kickball, basketball, tennis, and other games, with no parental supervision. I skinned my knees regularly. I drank out of the garden hose. I peed in the bushes -- I'm talking about as a 3 year old, not later.
In the summers, aside from vacation time, I was often bored. I read books. I played with my dolls. I played games with my brother or other kids in the neighborhood. I watched TV -- we only had 2 channels.
My mother had even more freedom than I did as a child, in the 1930's and 40's. She rode her bicycle everywhere and her parents often didn't know where she was or what she was doing. She went all over Atlanta.
I tried to parent as freely as I had been parented but it was an uphill battle.
I was horrified when my son started middle school and there were no more recess periods. I had recess right through 8th grade. Kids need to go outside and run around and play. My son would come home so wound up from school and needing a break that I felt sorry for him. If I could have done it I would have homeschooled him.
When I was in middle school I often skipped riding the bus home and just walked, usually alone. It was about a mile, through the neighborhood adjacent to ours. On pretty days I enjoyed walking more than riding the stuffy, smelly bus. One reason we bought this house was that it is walking distance to the middle school and the elementary school. My son walked home from both schools.
When I worked full-time, my kids knew that when Granny was in charge, they had to entertain themselves. I didn't let them watch TV or do computer stuff unless I was home and supervising. They played a lot of board games, or played outside. They walked to the pool without supervision, though. They rode bikes all over the neighborhood. I let them be "free range" as much as I felt was safe.
I think nowadays perhaps it isn't safe for kids to be quite as free as I was as a child, but I think parents need to let kids do some exploring on their own, to develop self-confidence.
Let them fix their own snacks. My brother and I are both excellent cooks, and love to cook.
Let them play unsupervised, without phones or computers or videogames.
Encourage them to make things without help, to do their own homework without being supervised, to have entire summer days where they have to entertain themselves.
Talk to them about history, music, family stories. Share ideas and encourage them to share.
It's important.
Recent Comments